Indoor Jungle Shop

Living Lightly

Living Lightly

Eco Claims in Ads: Too Much Information Can Lower Appeal

Eco Claims in Ads: Too Much Information Can Lower Appeal

A study finds that consumers react differently to eco-friendly product ads based on their green values.

As more shoppers weigh sustainability when they buy, you might expect products that advertise both green ingredients and eco-friendly packaging to win everyone over. New research suggests that strategy can actually backfire.

Consumer Reactions Vary

A study conducted by Miyuri Shirai, a professor at Keio University, revealed that while environmentally-conscious consumers prefer products that disclose both green ingredients and sustainable packaging, those who are less focused on eco-friendliness tend to respond better to ads that emphasize just one of these features.

Hence, more doesn't equal better. To better understand these dynamics, Shirai conducted three separate experiments involving 1,729 participants in Japan.

Shifting Trends in Green Products

The market for consumer packaged goods, such as soaps, cereals, and detergents, is increasingly leaning toward environmentally-friendly options. According to the NYU Stern Center for Sustainable Business, as of 2023, 18.5% of these goods in the U.S. were marketed as sustainable, reflecting a notable rise of 4.8 percentage points since 2015.

Research from McKinsey & Company and NielsenIQ further underscores this trend, showing that the sales of products with sustainability claims grew by 28% over the past five years, in contrast to a 20% increase for traditional offerings. This growth prompts companies to decide whether to make their products greener or to enhance their packaging.

Understanding Consumer Preferences

Initially, it might seem that highlighting two green features in a product's advertising would be more effective than just one. However, past behavioral studies, such as one involving Daniel Kahneman and Jack Knetsch in 1992, suggest that more information can potentially dilute value. This phenomenon, known as the embedding effect, sparked Shirai's interest in exploring consumer perceptions around sustainability claims.

For her experiments, Shirai recruited participants from the Freeasy online survey panel in Japan and presented them with fictional products. Each respondent viewed an advertisement that either focused solely on the product's ingredients, solely on its packaging, or combined both aspects. Subsequently, they rated the products based on their attractiveness.

Findings Across Product Categories

The research included three trials focusing on different products: laundry detergent, organic granola, and body wash. Findings were consistent across all products. Participants who prioritized green values rated products more highly when both sustainable attributes were highlighted compared to advertisements featuring just one aspect. Conversely, those with lower emphasis on green consumption rated products more favorably when only one sustainable feature was presented.

This disparity aligns with the embedding effect, indicating that a single green characteristic could appear more impactful when not overshadowed by additional information.

Personal Values Shape What Feels Useful

In the body wash trial, how useful participants found the environmental details closely tracked with their overall product ratings. Because evaluations shifted depending on each shopper's personal beliefs, existing attitudes clearly filter how people read sustainability labels.

Still, the experiment's setup left one variable tangled. Ads featuring both traits included four green statements, while single-feature ads included only two—making it harder to tell whether shoppers reacted to the types of claims or simply the amount of text.

Future Implications for Marketing

Matching environmental messaging to a shopper's existing values can make a product more appealing, though how that translates into actual store sales or real environmental gains remains unproven. Shirai's full study appears in the Journal of Environmental Psychology.